During the Sesame
(Synchrotron-light Experimental Science and Applications in the Middle-East)
Structural Molecular Biology (SMB) meeting in Cyprus in December 2000 (see the
SESAME web site www.sesame.org.jo for a report) ideas for future projects were
explored, keeping in mind the importance of developing a local user base for
SESAME and establishing strong collaborations among scientists from the region.
The idea for a bioinformatics workshop was conceived not only because
bioinformatics is a fast developing field which can be used to complement
structural studies carried out on synchrotrons, but also because bioinformatics
tools are on the World Wide Web and hence accessible to people even in parts of
the world where other facilities may not be present. People located in
different countries can share data and analysis skills, establish
collaborations and develop projects together in the electronic medium at a
relatively low cost.
Dr. Zehra Sayers offered to host the
'Bioinformatics and Structural Modelling' workshop/school at Sabanci University
(SU) near Istanbul and Drs. Irit Sagi (Weizmann Institute, Israel) and Metaxia
Vlassi (NCSR “Demokritos”, Greece) offered their help as
co-organisers. These three scientists met for the first time at the Cyprus SMB
workshop. With help from Dr. H. Winick, who is one of the driving forces behind
the SESAME project, it was possible to get sponsorship from UNESCO. TUBITAK
(Turkish National Scientific and Technical Research Council), Sabanci
University and the Israeli Synchrotron Radiation Fund also provided funds which
made it possible to cover local expenses and also to provide travel allowances
for all participants.
The workshop/school was at post-graduate level,
and the twenty-four students from different countries (including Armenia,
Bosnia and Herzegovina, Egypt, Greece, Israel, Jordan, Morocco, Poland, Turkey
and the USA) came from diverse disciplines such as medicine, computer science,
physics and biology.
The lecturers included C. Baysal (Sabanci
University, Turkey), I. Berezovsky (Weizmann Institute, Israel), E. Eliopoulos
(University of Athens, Greece), A. Gürsoy (Bilkent University, Turkey), D.
Lancet (Weizmann Institute, Israel), S. Mobashery (Wayne State University,
USA), R. Najmanovich (Weizmann Institute, Israel), P. Rizkallah (Daresbury
Laboratory, UK) I. Sagi (Weizmann Institute, Israel), Z. Sayers (Sabanci
University, Turkey), U. Sezerman (Sabanci University, Turkey), M. Vlassi (NCSR
“Demokritos”, Greece), S. Wakatsuki (Photon Facotry, Japan), H.
Winick (Stanford University,USA), A. Yonath (Weizmann Institute, Israel), and
P. Zielenkiewicz (Polish Academy of Sciences, Poland).
The workshop/school was designed to have lectures
in the morning and practical sessions in the afternoon. Lectures covered
introduction to experimental techniques for structure determination based on
synchrotron radiation, e.g. X-ray crystallography (M. Vlassi, P. Rizkallah),
small angle scattering (Z. Sayers) and EXAFS (I. Sagi). Complementarity of
results obtained with different techniques (Z. Sayers) as well as emergence of
novel methods for dynamic studies (I. Sagi) was emphasised. Analysis of the
crystallographicaly determined structures of bacterial ribosome and
ribosome-antibiotics complexes (A. Yonath) highlighted possibilities for drug
design. Structure based modelling and molecular dynamics simulations of
biological systems at scales from those of catalytic sites of enzymes to large
structures such as surface components of bacteria (S. Mobashary) provided
examples for how 3D modelling tools may be used for bridging experimental data
and developing alternative strategies for rational drug design. A survey of a
target oriented structural genomics project using synchrotron X-ray protein
Crystallography was also given (S. Wakatzuki). These lectures focused on
results obtained using various synchrotron radiation sources around the world
e.g. APS, Photon Factory, ESRF, DESY, Daresbury, SSRl and Brookhaven.
Talks on tools for utilisation of data from the
Human Genome project (D. Lancet) and new strategies for structural motif
recognition (I. Berezovsky) introduced different aspects of analysis of DNA and
protein sequence data bases. Secondary structure predictions (E. Eliopoulos),
molecular dynamics simulations (C. Baysal), homology modelling U. Sezerman),
threading (P. Zielenkiewcz) and docking methods (R. Najmanovich) were presented
both in lectures as well as used as topics for practical exercises.
Practical sessions were carried out in a computer
lab at SU equipped with 15 PCs and the necessary peripherals (e.g. printers,
multimedia facilities etc.). Each PC was used by a workgroup of two students,
that allowed everybody to gain direct experience.
Practical sessions were computer based exercises
in the form of tutorials prepared as web pages that were accessed through the
local website developed for the purposes of the workshop. The topics of each
day’s tutorial were related to the morning lectures and covered use of
web-based resources related to macromolecular structure: search and retrieval
(e.g. ENTREZ, SRS) of data from various databases (such as PFAM, PROSITE, MIME,
SwissProt and the PDB structural database), sequence similarity searches
(e.g.BLAST), sequence alignments (CLUSTALW, t-COFFEE), secondary structure
predictions (PHD, GOR-IV and Joint prediction: by Eliopoulos),
sequence-prototype based prediction of the closed loops (developed by I.
Berezovsky), homology modelling (SwissModel and 3D-PSSM), threading (developed
by P. Zielenkiewicz) and ligand-protein contact analysis (developed by R.
Najmanovich). Students were also introduced to 3D visualisation programs (e.g.
rasmol and Swiss-pdb viewer) which were used to display, compare and analyse
known 3D structures and models. One protein with unknown 3D structure belonging
to a well-studied protein family served as a test case for all practical
sessions.
Availability and rapid accumulation of DNA
sequence data necessitate heavy use of electronic means for storage,
transmission and analyses. Effective use of sequence-based information reveals
previously unknown relationships - ranging from the identification of unknown
genes to the prediction of protein structures. Parallel to improvements in
experimental methodologies for faster structural data collection and analysis,
computational tools are now being developed aimed at predicting structures and
elucidation of structure-function relationships as well as for drug design.
Today Web-based facilities such Entrez at NCBI or Biology Workbench at SDSC,
worldwide accessible databases e.g. Swiss Prot, PDB as well as web-based tools
(BLAST, CLUSTAL W), and servers for secondary structure predictions (e.g. PHD,
JOINT, GOR-IV) and 3D modelling (e.g. SwissModel, 3d-pssm) are at the disposal
of scientists from many countries. The ease of access to data and facilities
provide opportunities for competitive research regardless of the location of
the scientist.
The workshop/school confirmed that bioinformatics
and computational biology are emerging fields which could be developed in
SESAME countries as a prelude to the synchrotron activities. This would help to
build a user base with background in structural analysis and encourage
establishing collaborations in the region. A proposal, for a computational
facility that will be based in Jordan at the SESAME site, to be taken to
representatives of respective countries and to the SESAME Council, is being
prepared.
The great success of the workshop has opened a
window of new opportunities to expose young scientists to cutting edge
scientific projects and to train them in these fields. The nice and relaxed
scientific atmosphere has promoted scientific interactions and new hope for the
future of the Middle East region.
|